Buttermilk Yogurt Substitute: Can You Use Yogurt In Place of Buttermilk?

Imagine always having what you need for a recipe, even when you run out an important ingredient like buttermilk. The answer is to substitute yogurt for buttermilk, because it’s usually easier to find. When you substitute yogurt for buttermilk, you can keep on cooking without any problems.

Using Yogurt as a Substitute for Buttermilk

substitute greek yogurt for buttermilk

Here's the exciting part - homemade yogurt. Think about making your own yogurt at home. It's a fun and easy project, and once you've made it, you always have a fresh supply ready to go. Is yogurt good for you? When you make your own yogurt, you control what goes into it. This means no unwanted additives or preservatives, just pure, natural yogurt.

Making homemade yogurt also means you can play around with different flavors and textures. Want a thicker Greek-style yogurt? You can do that. Fancy adding some fruit or honey for a tasty twist? Go for it. Want to host a lovely brunch with a yogurt bar?  You’ll impress all your friends with homemade yogurt! And the best part is, because you made it, you can adjust it to your own taste.

Understanding Yogurt as a Buttermilk Substitute in Recipes

Buttermilk is a special type of milk that's a little bit thick and tastes tangy. It's used in a lot of recipes because it makes baked goods moist and helps them rise. But sometimes, it's hard to find buttermilk at the grocery store, and when you do, it's often more than what you need for a recipe.

That's where yogurt comes in. You can substitute yogurt for buttermilk in your recipes, and if it's homemade, it's even better. With homemade yogurt, you solve the problem of finding buttermilk and you get to explore more flavors in your cooking.

download yogurt guide and recipe book

Trying Out Different Buttermilk Substitutes

It's time to take a closer look at the different options for replacing buttermilk in your recipes. There's more than just yogurt that can save the day.

Yogurt: Remember, our superhero in the kitchen? Substitute yogurt for buttermilk. Just use the same amount of yogurt as the recipe calls for buttermilk. For the right thickness, you might need to mix it with a little water.

Sour cream: Sour cream substitute works well too! Just like with yogurt, use the same amount of sour cream as you would buttermilk. Also, just like yogurt, it’s even better homemade!  You might need to add a little water to make it less thick.

Cream of tartar with milk: This combination is another good choice. To prevent clumping, mix the cream of tartar with the dry ingredients and then add the milk. 

Kefir: Kefir is a lot like buttermilk and can be used in the same way. If your recipe calls for buttermilk, use the same amount of kefir. This is another ideal ingredient you can make yourself to always have on hand.  And bonus!  It’s a great, gut-healthy drink.

Lemon or vinegar with milk: Here's an interesting one. You can mix a little lemon juice or vinegar with milk to make a substitute for buttermilk. These are ingredients that most people always have on hand.

Non-dairy milk: For those who prefer non-dairy options, you can use alternatives like almond or oat milk instead of buttermilk, just be sure to add a splash of acid when baking to ensure the correct pH level. A bit of lemon juice, vinegar, or cream of tartar will do the trick.

Greek Yogurt Starter Culture

Trust points for Greek Yogurt Starter Culture
There’s a reason Greek Yogurt is one of our most popular products! Make tangy, rich, and delicious yogurt at home for a fraction of the cost of store-bought.  Using a starter culture allows you to control the ingredients, making your Greek Yogurt much healthier. The Greek Yogurt Starter is an heirloom...

Making Homemade Yogurt and Buttermilk

Now, for the part you've been waiting for - making homemade yogurt and buttermilk. It's easier than you think, and it's a fun project that can make your cooking even better.

Cultures for Health can help with this. They offer products that help you make your own yogurt and buttermilk at home. With their help, you'll always have fresh ingredients ready for your recipes.

When you make your own yogurt and buttermilk, you control everything. This means you decide what goes in it - no unnecessary stuff from the store-bought versions. Plus, you can experiment with flavors and textures.

The process of making homemade yogurt and buttermilk might seem like a big task, but once you get the hang of it, it's pretty simple. And the best part? You'll have an endless supply of buttermilk and yogurt for all your delicious recipes.

Steps to Make Homemade Yogurt and Buttermilk

Are you ready to make your own yogurt and buttermilk? Don't worry, it's not as hard as it sounds, and it can be lots of fun! Here's how to do it:

First, let's start with yogurt. You'll need some yogurt starter cultures from Cultures for Health to get started. These are the tiny, helpful bacteria that turn milk into yogurt. You just mix them with milk, then let it sit in a warm place for a while. After that, you have fresh, homemade yogurt!

Now, for buttermilk. It's a similar process. You just need some buttermilk starter from Cultures for Health, mix it with milk, and let it sit. After a while, you'll have tangy, creamy buttermilk ready to use in your recipes.

Using Homemade Yogurt and Buttermilk in Your Recipes

substitute greek yogurt for buttermilk

Now that you know how to make your own yogurt and buttermilk, think about all the yummy things you can make. Homemade yogurt and buttermilk can be used in so many ways!

For example, you can use them to make tender, flaky biscuits. Or how about pancakes? They'll be light and fluffy with your homemade yogurt or buttermilk. Perhaps a dutch pancake?  This one will really let you taste the tang of the buttermilk!  And don't forget about cakes. Your homemade yogurt and buttermilk can make them extra moist and tasty. You can even use them in waffles for a special breakfast treat. You can substitute yogurt for buttermilk interchangeably most of the time, so go ahead and try it out in your favorite recipe!

Yogurt: More Than a Buttermilk Substitute

So, you see, making homemade yogurt and buttermilk isn't just about having a substitute when you run out. It's about exploring new flavors, getting creative in the kitchen, and making your food even tastier.

So why not give it a try? Get some live cultures from Cultures for Health and start making your own yogurt and buttermilk today. Your cooking adventures are about to get a whole lot more exciting. Happy cooking!